| 11 | Brooklyn/Los Angeles Dodgers-New York Yankees | Yankees (8-3) | 1941, 1947, 1949, 1952, 1953, 1955, 1956, 1963, 1977, 1978, 1981 |
| 7 | New York Yankees-New York/San Francisco Giants | Yankees (5-2) | 1921, 1922, 1923, 1936, 1937, 1951, 1962 |
| 5 | New York Yankees-St. Louis Cardinals | Cardinals (3-2) | 1926, 1928, 1942, 1943, 1964 |
| 4 | Chicago Cubs-Detroit Tigers | Empate (2-2) | 1907, 1908, 1935, 1945 |
| Oakland Athletics-San Francisco Giants | Athletics (3-1) | 1905, 1911, 1913, 1989 |
| Atlanta Braves-New York Yankees | Yankees (3-1) | 1957, 1958, 1996, 1999 |
| Boston Red Sox-St. Louis Cardinals | Empate (2-2) | 1946, 1967, 2004, 2013 |
| 3 | Cincinnati Reds vs. New York Yankees | Yankees (2-1) | 1939, 1961, 1976 |
| Detroit Tigers vs. St. Louis Cardinals | Cardinals (2-1) | 1934, 1968, 2006 |
| 2 | Chicago Cubs-Philadelphia Athletics | Athletics (2-0) | 1910, 1929 |
| Philadelphia Athletics-St. Louis Cardinals | Empate (1-1) | 1930, 1931 |
| Washington Senators-New York Giants | Empate (1-1) | 1924, 1933 |
| Chicago Cubs-New York Yankees | Yankees (2-0) | 1932, 1938 |
| New York Yankees-Pittsburgh Pirates | Empate (1-1) | 1927, 1960 |
| Baltimore Orioles-Pittsburgh Pirates | Pirates (2-0) | 1971, 1979 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers-Oakland Athletics | Empate (1-1) | 1974, 1988 |
| Cincinnati Reds-Oakland Athletics | Empate (1-1) | 1972, 1990 |
| Atlanta Braves-Cleveland Guardians | Empate (1-1) | 1948, 1995 |
| New York Yankees-Philadelphia Phillies | Yankees (2-0) | 1950, 2009 |
| Boston Red Sox-Brooklyn/Los Ángeles Dodgers | Red Sox (2-0) | 1916, 2018 |
| 1 | Boston Red Sox-Pittsburgh Pirates | Red Sox (1-0) | 1903 |
| Chicago Cubs-Chicago White Sox | White Sox (1-0) | 1906 |
| Detroit Tigers-Pittsburgh Pirates | Pirates (1-0) | 1909 |
| Boston Red Sox-New York Giants | Red Sox (1-0) | 1912 |
| Boston Braves-Philadelphia Athletics | Athletics (1-0) | 1914 |
| Boston Red Sox-Philadelphia Phillies | Red Sox (1-0) | 1915 |
| Chicago White Sox-New York Giants | White Sox (1-0) | 1917 |
| Boston Red Sox-Chicago Cubs | Red Sox (1-0) | 1918 |
| Chicago White Sox-Cincinnati Reds | Reds (1-0) | 1919 |
| Cleveland Guardians-Brooklyn Dodgers | Guardians (1-0) | 1920 |
| Washington Senators-Pittsburgh Pirates | Pirates (1-0) | 1925 |
| Cincinnati Reds-Detroit Tigers | Reds (1-0) | 1940 |
| Baltimore Orioles-St. Louis Cardinals | Cardinals (1-0) | 1944 |
| Cleveland Guardians-New York Giants | Giants (1-0) | 1954 |
| Chicago White Sox-Los Angeles Dodgers | Dodgers (1-0) | 1959 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers-Minnesota Twins | Dodgers (1-0) | 1965 |
| Baltimore Orioles-Los Angeles Dodgers | Orioles (1-0) | 1966 |
| Baltimore Orioles-New York Mets | Mets (1-0) | 1969 |
| Baltimore Orioles-Cincinnati Reds | Orioles (1-0) | 1970 |
| New York Mets-Oakland Athletics | Athletics (1-0) | 1973 |
| Boston Red Sox-Cincinnati Reds | Reds (1-0) | 1975 |
| Philadelphia Phillies-Kansas City Royals | Phillies (1-0) | 1980 |
| Milwaukee Brewers-St. Louis Cardinals | Cardinals (1-0) | 1982 |
| Baltimore Orioles-Philadelphia Phillies | Orioles (1-0) | 1983 |
| Detroit Tigers-San Diego Padres | Tigers (1-0) | 1984 |
| Kansas City Royals-St. Louis Cardinals | Royals (1-0) | 1985 |
| Boston Red Sox-New York Mets | Mets (1-0) | 1986 |
| Minnesota Twins-St. Louis Cardinals | Twins(1-0) | 1987 |
| Atlanta Braves-Minnesota Twins | Twins (1-0) | 1991 |
| Atlanta Braves-Toronto Blue Jays | Blue Jays (1-0) | 1992 |
| Philadelphia Phillies-Toronto Blue Jays | Blue Jays (1-0) | 1993 |
| Cleveland Guardians-Florida Marlins | Marlins (1-0) | 1997 |
| New York Yankees-San Diego Padres | Yankees (1-0) | 1998 |
| New York Mets-New York Yankees | Yankees (1-0) | 2000 |
| Arizona Diamondbacks-New York Yankees | Diamondbacks (1-0) | 2001 |
| Anaheim Angels-San Francisco Giants | Angels (1-0) | 2002 |
| Florida Marlins-New York Yankees | Marlins (1-0) | 2003 |
| Chicago White Sox-Houston Astros | White Sox (1-0) | 2005 |
| Boston Red Sox-Colorado Rockies | Red Sox (1-0) | 2007 |
| Philadelphia Phillies-Tampa Bay Rays | Phillies (1-0) | 2008 |
| San Francisco Giants-Texas Rangers | Giants (1-0) | 2010 |
| St. Louis Cardinals-Texas Rangers | Cardinals (1-0) | 2011 |
| San Francisco Giants-Detroit Tigers | Giants (1-0) | 2012 |
| San Francisco Giants-Kansas City Royals | Giants (1-0) | 2014 |
| Kansas City Royals-New York Mets | Royals (1-0) | 2015 |
| Chicago Cubs – Cleveland Guardians | Cubs (1-0) | 2016 |
| Houston Astros – Los Angeles Dodgers | Astros (1-0) | 2017 |
| Washington Nationals – Houston Astros | Nationals (1-0) | 2019 |
| Tampa Bay Rays – Los Angeles Dodgers | Dodgers (1-0) | 2020 |
| Atlanta Braves – Houston Astros | Braves (1-0) | 2021 |
| Philadelphia Phillies – Houston Astros | Astros (1-0) | 2022 |
| Arizona Diamondbacks – Texas Rangers | Rangers (1-0) | 2023 |
